Mike Postle Granted Second Continuance in $330 Million Libel Case4 months ago
A California Superior Court judge has granted a second continuation to accused poker cheat Mike Postle in his $330 million libel case against a dozen of his most prominent online accusers. Postle, of Sacramento, California, received a 33-day continuation on Thursday, buying him additional time to bring on replacement counsel for his high-profile lawsuit.
Postle claimed in a statement in an online hearing before presiding judge Shama H. Mesiwala that it may be a couple of weeks before he would have replacement counsel. When pressed, Postle claimed to be waiting until “next week” on a decision from an unspecified law firm as to whether it would represent him. Postle also asserted that he was seeking a continuance of up to 120 days to allow the unnamed law firm to come up to speed and to allow additional discovery in the case to occur.
Attorneys for two of the case’s 12 defendants, Veronica Brill and Todd Witteles, were on hand to argue that if any second continuance was granted, it should be of a far shorter duration. Judge Mesiwala herself noted the highly unusual circumstances, declaring:
“It’s pretty rare that you can come to court and just ask for a continuance. It’s usually done on what we call an ex parte calendar. So even the fact that I’m entertaining this now is pretty unusual.”Nonetheless, the judge granted Postle his shorter-than-hoped-for continuance, with the next hearing scheduled for April 20, 2021. Judge Mesiwala also declared that granting an anti-SLAPP (Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation) motion already filed by Witteles and Brill would be a “draconian” solution, despite multiple deficiencies to date in Postle’s legal complaint.
In a countering argument, in one of only a couple of mildly heated moments in what was generally a brief and congenial hearing, Brill attorney Marc Randazza argued that California law demanded an anti-SLAPP motion be ruled upon in 30 days, one continuance had already been granted, and it was also draconian for the case’s defendants to perpetually have a “$300 million lawsuit” hanging over their heads. Judge Mesiwala noted the validity of that argument yet still chose the middle road, granting Postle the time extension but forcing him to move quickly before the next court date.
Postle has represented himself since his original attorney filed a motion to be recused from the case in December, with that motion being granted in January. One point not brought by the judge or by either side was that Postle, in his filing for the second continuation, claimed that his first attorney, Steven T. Lowe, had dropped out of the lawsuit over a lack of experience in online-defamation litigation. However, Lowe cited Postle’s lack of communication and a breach of attorney/client contract in filing his successful recusal motion.
Perhaps the most heated assertion came from Randazza when he stated:
"This complaint was filed as a public relations stunt."
Judge Mesiwala quickly intervened and officially announced her ruling. She had already released a preliminary ruling on Wednesday essentially announcing the second continuance would be granted, but she was disappointed by the two sides not being able to agree on the continuance’s length before the hearing began.
The other appearing defense attorney, Eric Benzamochan (for Witteles), complained that Postle continued to dawdle in hiring an attorney but had already retained a PR firm. Though not confirmed directly in court, the remark appeared to relate a Tweet made by defendant Brill on Wednesday. In Postle’s motion for the second continuation, he wrote:
"Plaintiff has just retained an organization specializing in internet based First Amendment and defamation issues…"Brill, likely after learning of Mesiwala’s preliminary ruling the day before, Tweeted this:
Imagine if a cheater in poker contacted the HONR Network.— Veronica Brill 2.2 (@Angry_Polak) March 18, 2021
A group founded by one of the parents of a Sandy Hook mass shooting victim to respond to people attacked online by conspiracy theorists, trolls, and financial opportunists.
Imagine if he convinced them to help him..... wow
Neither Postle nor the HONR Network has rebutted Brill’s claim to date, while Benzamochan also referenced an exhibit -- as yet publicly unseen -- filed into the case by Postle on February 28th. Benzamochan did not specify the exhibit’s contents or creator.
No trial date has been set in the case. Attorneys for 10 of the 12 defendants, including such prominent entities as ESPN and PokerNews, have not even bothered to appear; according to Witteles’ anti-SLAPP motion, none of the defendants were even properly notified -- in legal terms -- of the $330 million lawsuit’s filing.
If you missed anything connected to the case over the past year, our extensive coverage of the Postlegate scandal can be viewed below:
- Sick Heater or Sick Cheater? StonesLive Player Under Suspicion
- Updates on Mike Postle Poker Cheating Scandal at StonesLive
- Mike Postle Denies Cheating Allegations On The Mouthpiece Podcast
- Is Mike Postle Really A Cheat?
- Mike Postle, Stones and Kuraitis Named in $10million Cheating Scandal Lawsuit
- Veronica Brill - The Real Hero Of The Stones Live Poker Cheating Scandal
- Has Matt Berkey Discovered The Postlegate Cheating Method?
- Is Jonathan Little Unfairly Cashing in on Postlegate Scandal?
- Top 5 Hands Mike Postle Allegedly Cheated On Stones Live Cash Game
- Postlegate Whistleblower Veronica Brill Reveals Inner Workings of Stones Cheating Scandal
- Mike Postle Will Not Go To Jail Over Cheating Scandal
- Mike Postle In Hiding As $10Million Lawsuit Heads To Court
- Mike Postle's Magazine Releases Anonymous Article Casting Doubt on Cheating Claims
- Anonymous Claims That Mike Postle Played At Other Casinos During Alleged Cheating Streak
- Alleged Poker Cheat Mike Postle Finally Acknowledges $10million Lawsuit
- Another Delay in Mike Postle Cheating Case
- Stones Gambling Hall Asks for Postlegate Cheating Case to be Dismissed
- Mike Postle Files Response in Poker-Cheating Case
- New Defense Briefs and Alleged Victims Lawsuits Filed as Postlegate Continues
- Second Lawsuit Filed Over Mike Postle Poker Cheating Allegations
- Mike Postle Amends Dismissal Motion in Poker Cheating Case
- Plaintiffs Seek Sanctions Against Alleged Poker Cheat Mike Postle
- Mike Postle Accused of Dodging Legal Service in Second Poker Cheating Case
- Mike Postle Cheating Lawsuit: Plaintiffs File Response to Stones’ Denial of Responsibility
- Stones Gambling Hall, Kings Casino File Amended Motions to Dismiss Postlegate Lawsuit
- Shock as Mike Postle Cheating Case Dismissed by Judge
- Mike Postle Fights to Dismiss Nevada Cheating Lawsuit by Marle Cordeiro
- Settlement Talks Disclosed Between Stones Gambling Hall, Alleged Cheating Victims
- Veronica Brill Shocked by Postlegate Netflix Documentary Claims
- Nevada-based Lawsuit Against Mike Postle Dismissed For Lack of Jurisdiction
- Whistleblower Veronica Brill Not Among 60 Players Who Accept Settlement in Postlegate Scandal
- Mike Postle and Justin Kuraitis Speak Out as Mac Verstandig Admits No Forensic Evidence of Cheating
- Poker Pros Trash Justin Kuraitis Pro-Postle Statement
- Postlegate $40,000 Payoff More Than Lawsuit ‘Rake’ Damages
- Bart Hanson Dissects New Postlegate Hands as Justin Kuraitis Sets Twitter Alight
- Mike Postle Movie Producer Promises It's Not Just An Innocence Film
- Justin Kuraitis Goes Quiet On Twitter Following Postlegate Backlash
- Mike Postle Launches $330million Defamation Lawsuit Against Brill, Negreanu, Ingram and Others
- Veronica Brill Launches GoFundMe Campaign for Mike Postle Libel Lawsuit Legal Fees
- Inside Mike Postle’s $330million Defamation Conspiracy Lawsuit: Who He Is Suing And Why
- Todd Witteles Hires Beverly Hills Lawyer to Defend Against Mike Postle Accusations
- Mike Postle’s Attorney Files Motion to Exit Case, Citing Compliance and Communication Failures
- Todd Witteles to File Frivolous-Lawsuit Claim in Mike Postle Libel Case
- February Hearings Approach for Anti-SLAPP Motions in Mike Postle Libel Lawsut
- Mike Postle’s Internet Trolls Disappear Along with Alleged Cheat
- Mike Postle Files For Second Continuation, Todd Witteles Files Opposing Motion
Want poker news as it breaks? Join the Poker News and Gossip Telegram channel!
Did you like this article?Tweet +0